Bolsonaro sanctions law ending tax role of ANS – 09/21/2022 – Daily

President Jair Bolsonaro (PL) sanctioned this Wednesday (21) the invoice that obliges well being plans to pay for therapies that aren’t on the principle reference listing of the ANS (National Supplementary Health Agency).

The proposal ends the so-known as tax role of the ANO. And in doing so, it restores the role of an instance by specifying that the company’s listing of procedures serves solely as a reference for well being plans — and doesn’t imply that the gadgets contained within the doc are the one ones to be lined.

Therefore, beneficiaries of the plans can request protection of therapies that aren’t listed. It is simply needed that there be scientific proof or that the remedy is acknowledged by a overseas company.

In late August, the National Congress completed processing the invoice ending the tax role of the ANS. The legislative initiative got here in response to a ruling by the STJ (Supreme Court), which dominated in June that well being plans wouldn’t be required to cowl therapies exterior the company’s listing.

The complementary well being sector was already ready for the president’s sanction, because it believed that it was a political determination and a doable veto would acquire loads of traction two weeks earlier than the election. In current weeks, Minister Marcelo Queiroga (Health) has already advised his interlocutors that he won’t advocate the CEO’s veto.

Position represents a change within the posture of the folder’s proprietor. In a Senate debate session forward of the House vote, Queiroga criticized the invoice, saying approval would have a significant affect on the sector.

“In selecting to have extra procedures, extra medicine on the listing, there’ll essentially be prices that will likely be handed on to the beneficiaries. And some of them will be unable to afford these prices. This is the fact,” stated the minister occasionally.

“It was a lot simpler for me to come back right here and defend an exemplary and broad listing, however it’s as much as the well being minister to alert the senators who will likely be analyzing this proposal, what are probably the most applicable methods to make sure well being not solely by proper of all and responsibility of the state, but in addition throughout the scope of personal well being plans,” he added.

The rapporteur of the proposal within the Senate, Romário (PL-RJ), celebrated on his social networks the approval of the invoice.

“This means thousands and thousands of individuals’s therapies, therapies and medicines will as soon as once more be paid for by their well being plans.” This is a victory for LIFE!” the parliamentarian wrote. “We had been blackmailed and threatened, however life is a non-negotiable proper. We did it!!! Always rely on me!” he added.

The invoice additionally amends the Health Plans Act (the Plans Act) to make operators topic to the Consumer Protection Code, which isn’t the case in the present day.

The General Secretariat of the Presidency didn’t say whether or not it had vetoed the proposal by the point this report was printed. The act have to be promulgated within the State Gazette of the Union.


A fierce critic of the exemplary role, Abramge (Brazilian Association of Health Plans) says the law could lead on the sector to break down and regrets the “lack of a deeper technical debate”.

“[A lei] obligates well being plans to cowl therapies, procedures and medicines that haven’t been included in any nation on the planet, which can result in severe dangers for affected person security and could lead on the Brazilian personal and public well being sector to a systemic collapse,” it stated the notice despatched by the topic.

“Since the law was handed, well being plans in Brazil must present or cowl therapies, procedures and medicines with none proof of security of their use; and which aren’t included in any nation on the planet – which can go away Brazilians uncovered to severe social safety dangers,” provides Abramge. “We are exposing the danger that medicine and different applied sciences will likely be examined for the primary time on well being plan beneficiaries.”

FenaSaúde (National Federation of Supplementary Health) additionally regrets that the ANS listing has been categorized as a pattern listing and says it’s contemplating going to court docket.

“The change places Brazil in opposition to the world’s greatest practices for evaluating the inclusion of medicine and well being procedures, makes it troublesome to correctly plan costs and compromises the predictability of care prices, which might result in excessive month-to-month charges and the mass expulsion of beneficiaries of complementary well being care” , FenaSaúde says in a notice.

In a notice to Sheet, the ANS has proven concern for the security of customers of complementary well being. “Covering well being procedures and occasions that haven’t gone by the regulator’s intensive and cautious evaluation poses a threat to sufferers as a result of it doesn’t consider a number of standards evaluated within the course of of implementing well being applied sciences, resembling: security, effectiveness, accuracy, efficacy , value-effectiveness and funds affect, along with having a community of suppliers and approval from skilled councils relating to its use.”

The company additionally pressured that the listing overview course of won’t be modified. “The company will proceed to obtain and analyze inclusion proposals by FormRol on an ongoing foundation, with inclusions that may occur at any time and with broad social participation,” he concluded.

Marcos Roberto Tavares, a head and neck surgeon at Hospital das Clínicas in Sao Paulo, stated Abramgue and FenaSaude are unsuitable once they say that any process or examination must be carried out. He emphasizes that analysis is one exercise and utilizing the strategies developed within the analysis is one other.

“A physician can’t make a remedy that involves his thoughts with out scientific proof. He has to do what’s written within the medical literature. It might even be that some loopy physician needed to make an modern remedy, nevertheless it needs to be permitted in analysis,” says Tavares.

He cited the instance of what turned identified within the Nineties as a “most cancers capsule” that was promoted by USP professor Gilberto Chierice with out the existence of research to show its effectiveness. After eight months, a examine funded by the Sao Paulo authorities was stopped as a result of a scarcity of “vital scientific profit” for sufferers.

“The medical council should act extra strongly to keep away from the indiscriminate use of uncommon strategies. Even the well being fund itself can go to the council to see if the remedy is bioethical,” he stated.

OAB-SP (Brazilian Bar Association) Medical and Health Law Commission President Juliana Peneda Jasé Thompson de Godoy says that in the first place there could also be a rise in authorized proceedings.

“It is vital to emphasise that though this truth means a victory for the thousands and thousands of well being plan beneficiaries within the nation, it’s needed to watch the impacts ensuing from this legislative change, bearing in mind the monetary capability of the well being plan operators and the inherent mutualism to medical help contracts,” the president stated.

Idec (Brazilian Institute for Consumer Protection) in flip states that the non-veto sanction is “an undisputed victory for shoppers and affected person organizations, fathers and moms of autistic kids with cerebral palsy”.

“This is the fruits of the efforts of these organizations and the popularity by the authorities not solely of the significance of the topic, but in addition of the necessity to direct the market of well being plans to guard life,” says Ana Carolina Navarrete, coordinator of Idec’s Health.

For activist Andrea Werner, mom of a young person identified with ASD (autism spectrum dysfunction), this can be a “historic victory”.

“We have received, as Senator Randolfe Rodríguez stated, probably the most highly effective foyer in Brazil, and it’s not daily that we win monetary energy on this nation. This is a historic victory for households who’ve been shedding out on remedy, treatment and residential care,” Werner stated, quoting the congressman from the Network in late August, after PL’s passage within the Senate.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.